Sometimes Breaking the Law is the right thing

Sometimes Breaking the Law is the right thing

Dear Friends,

I am so pleased that the School Board last night chose to follow the CDC and medical professionals by bringing a mask mandate to the schools.  School Board members mentioned how many calls they had received; speaking up really does work.

I was especially pleased that the conversation was not primarily about their concerns about breaking the law (the mandate against mask mandate), but rather about keeping children safe.

Judaism has always taught that we are responsible for our own actions.  We can never defend our actions by claiming that we were told to do it.  The first example of this is Shifrah and Puah, the Egyuptian midwives who simply did not comply with Pharoah’s decree to kill the babies.  As Jews, we have a religious obligation never to comply with unethical laws.

The Talmud has a principle ein shaliach ledavar aveirah–literally, “there’s no such thing as an agent for a sin.”  Normally, I can send you to do something for me, like buy milk at the store–you bought it but it’s mine.  You were my agent, and your actions are counted as mine.  But if I ask you to do a sin, you cannot say you are my “agent” and are just representing me; the sin is on you, no matter who directed you to do it.  This is our response to the Milgram experiment, in which people “electrocuted” other people based on the directive of a “doctor.”  If it looks wrong, we don’t do it.  We are always responsible for our own actions.

Please join us as we prepare for the High Holidays by examining our life in an open hearted way, with music, readings, and contemplation. Selichot is August 31st at 8:30.

Shabbat Shalom,

Rabbi David Siff

Thank you to Sam Kessler for his generous contribution to Kol HaLev.

Please consider contributing to Kol HaLev this new year; your contribution helps us offer meaningful worship, community, and education in Palm Beach County and nationally.

Other Upcoming events:

  • High Holidays with Congregation Gan Eden: please join me on zoom with Congregation Gan Eden; tickets for the virtual service are available at
  • Sharing Joy and Thanksgiving: Sukkot dinner and song fest with Julius Sanna, Sept 24 6:00 (tickets required
  • Sukkot Family Festival Sept 26th

Jewish Virtual Academy: substantive, engaging online Jewish learning!

Try the classes that kids say are a “bajillion” times better than Hebrew School!

Students love our classes because they actually learn something relevant to their lives.  Our teachers are experts at bringing deep Torah learning to kids in an engaging way.

  • A La Carte Virtual Judaics: Mitzvah Class, Torah & Today, Torah Through Drama, & Moot Court Competition
  • Classes start October 4th (note the change in date); registration due September 10th

Try out our virtual academy for free:

  • Torah and Today: “Shaming”  Study with Rabbi Andrew Shapiro Katz examining the line between encouragement and shaming, and whether shaming is ever appropriate  (grades 6-12), August 30th, 5:00; register here
  • Mitzvah Class: “When is repentance complete?” taught by Sarah Rosenson (grades 2-6) September 13th, 5:00. register here.

more details on our programs at

registration packet HERE

Generous scholarships available–we make Jewish education available to all regardless of financial status

To register or further questions, contact